Amaya Espinal, aka Amaya Papaya, won over the internet thanks to her catchy one-liners and likable nature. And eventually, she won the entire show. Amaya and Bryan Arenales were named the winners of "Love Island USA" Season 7, based on votes from U.S. audiences, during the July 13 finale. They chose to split the $100,000 prize.

Theories attempting to piece together the facts of the breakup circulated the Internet in the following days until Craig finally confirmed that she and Rodriguez had officially parted ways. She also implied that the split was anything but amicable.