The Women, by T.C. Boy...
Reviewed on www.walmart.com·actonbell
The Women, by T.C. Boyle, is a novel that depicts the relationships the famous American architect Frank Lloyd Wright had with four women in his life. Boyle creates a narrator for this saga, one Sato Tadashi, a young man from Japan who reveres the famous architect and has come to Wisconsin to be one of Wright's apprentices at Taliesin. Even though this is a novel, and Tadashi is an invented character, almost all the events depicted in this book are known to be true. I found Boyle's way of expanding on these facts to be fascinating, and I also really liked Tadashi. He is an excellent vehicle to speak for the apprentices, who paid tuition to Wright so that they could work their backsides off, spending more time at their farm chores than at their drawing boards. Tadashi also has the bad luck of being at Taliesin during the bombing of Pearl Harbor, and so spends WWII in an internment camp. I kept forgetting that Tadashi was a fictional man, Boyle's deft depiction of how these obscure apprentices sacrificed years of their lives to be near greatness, and also a reminder of the prejudices of the times. Boyle chooses to introduce us to these women in reverse order, going back in time, since Tadashi arrives in the 1930s in time to meet Wrieto-San's last wife. However, I will mention them in chronological order, as is my wont: Wright's first wife was Catherine "Kitty" Tobin, just seventeen years old when she married him in 1899. They had six children. Boyle does not fill in many details of this relationship for us, since Kitty must have had her hands full with children and housework, while Frank was out hustling commissions to support his large family. The one common thread stitched into all these stories is that Frank doesn't pay his bills. Kitty is the one who is left to feel uncomfortable everytime she gets groceries, being constantly reminded of their ever-growing debt. Frank is oblivious to these--little troubles, and always seems to have everything he wants. Speaking of that, it is not long before Frank decides that he wants to be married to the wife of one of his clients. While designing a house for Edwin Cheney, he runs off to Europe with Edwin's wife, Mamah Borthwick Cheney. They both abandon their spouses and children in an act that is seen as immoral and selfish, and the scandal that follows almost ruins Frank's career. Kitty doesn't even know of this until the reporters come for her statement. This was Frank at his cruelest. Frank and Mamah lived together without the benefit of marriage, and for this they were generally shunned, especially Mamah. (Frank's women always suffered.) It was somewhat ironic that Mamah was very much interested in the feminist movement and working on a translation of a feminist writer's work while living at Taliesin, the home Frank built for the two of them, when she was tragically murdered by a servant named Julian Carlton. ( Taliesin murders ) Seven people were murdered that day, including Mamah's visiting children, who were 12 and 9 years old. I found myself worrying about the fate of the murderer's young wife Gertrude, who was certainly not involved. The motive is still unknown, but Boyle imagines a very likely one. Soon after Mamah's shocking death, while Frank is still mourning and vulnerable, a woman named Maude "Miriam" Noel insinuates her way into his life, and this is the start of a very bad time; Miriam is portrayed as the worst kind of opportunist, and she was definitely addicted to morphine. This marriage is over within a year, and while Frank is separated from Miriam, he meets Olga Lazovich Hinzenburg, or Olgivanna for--short, who will be his last wife. His early days with Olgivanna are marred by Miriam. The way she torments, harasses, and actually stalks Frank and Olgivanna, even after being offered a very reasonable divorce settlement, would probably land Miriam in jail today, or at least rehab. Actually, my only real criticism of this novel is that there's too much Miriam in it, even though I realize that Frank's battle with her lasted a long time, possibly three times longer than their short marriage. In short, it was incredibly ugly and tedious. Overall, I enjoyed this novel very much, and can see why Boyle decided to portray Wright's wives in reverse order, since it made for a more climatic ending than the other way around. How Frank Lloyd Wright managed to create such marvelous work with all this going on in the background is a mystery.
See moreSee lessThe Women in the rec...
Reviewed on www.walmart.com·Gary10
"The Women" in the recent book by TC Boyle are the three wives that occupied much of the adult life of super architect Frank Lloyd Wright. This is familiar territory for TC Boyle, who recently chronicled the life of sex research pioneer Alfred Kinsey. In fact, there are some important parallels between the men. Both were driven to be the best at what they did, both were impatient task masters with their workers, both inspired these same workers to be virtual servants. In important ways, both men attracted groupies-both male and female. The morality of both men also caused them serious problems and both struggled mightily against the puritanical prudishness of Middle America in the first half of the twentieth century. Both men also strayed from their wives. But while Kinsey remained more or less devoted to one woman, Wright was more of a serial monogamist. In particular, the three women he chose to marry each changed his life in major and often unpredictable ways. The way that Boyle tells the Wright story is also distinctive. He gives each of the three wives a major section to tell her story and he begins with wife number three and works backward in time to Wright's first wife. The fact that we learn about Wright through his wives produces a memorable kind of biography. I kept feeling like Wright was being built up from the inside out, where we get interpretations of his feelings and emotions and attitudes but always one step removed from the author of these attitudes and emotions. The biography is rendered even more complex by the fact that each wife has a distinctly different image of Wright and because the story is told through the wives' eyes, we never really know if these differences are produced by their differing interpretations or because Wright really was s different person in each relationship. One thing about Wright is clear: he needed a woman in his life. He was clearly incomplete without a female companion and despite the enormous pain that the women in his life caused him, he remained utterly devoted to the transformative hope of marriage. And perhaps one of his strongest characteristics as a human being is that he inspired women to love him-sometimes too deeply and destructively for anyone's own good. Boyle's decision to reverse the order of the wives in time also works as a literary strategy. While the chronological order complicates the story telling, it provides a very natural, and in the end, very moving progression. And above all this is a well written account, packed full of sentences like this: "The sky hadn't yet gone fully dark-it was a deep glowing tincture, of cobalt shading to black in the east, a western sky, poked through with the glittering holes of the stars-but the grounds were dense with shadow." You come for the story but stay for the writing.
See moreSee lessFor Historical Fiction Fans
Reviewed on www.walmart.com·Akbaird
This book follows the life of Frankie McGrath who comes from a wealthy conservative family where she was sheltered growing up. All she was ever taught was how to be a good homemaker and mother, which would be the expectations set by her parents and society. \n\nAt her brother, Finley's, going away party because he is going to war, she is told by Rye, her brother's best friend, that “women can be heroes”. This really struck her and made her think. \n\nWhen she had her first nursing job, it opened her eyes to the world around her. After doing a dead end job and taking care of an injured Vietnam soldier, she decides to join the Army Nurse Corp! How will she handle war? Will she get the experience she is looking for? \n\nWhen Frankie returns from war, there are protests going on and civil unrest. Frankie is having nightmares and is often spooked by everyday sounds. How will she cope with all she has been through? Can she find a life she is satisfied with? This book will keep you turning the pages to find out Frankie's fate! \n\nKristin Hannah, no matter what she writes, is refreshing to read! You can tell she takes the time to meticulously research in order to tell this story accurately and with dignity. She gives you a better understanding of what it was like during the Vietnam War through the eyes of women. Kristin Hannah sheds light and much deserved attention to the forgotten women of the Vietnam War! Anyone who is a fan of Historical Fiction, this is a must-read! Great for book clubs as well as it will lead to many great discussions!
See moreSee lessThe best compliment I could...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
The best compliment I could ever give an author is this…I feel educated…finally. Because enjoy and respect Kristin Hannah’s work-both an understatement-I preordered this book with complete trust that it would be wonderful. What I did not expect was to be thoroughly educated on a time that I heard about growing up, but never really learned about. It was not taught in school and I’m sure if had been it would’ve fallen grievously short of reality. So many young men and women from my rural small town are Vietnam Vets. While I did respect them, I had no idea the pain I was surrounded by my entire life nor the heroism, the inhuman strength they possess. I knew a man, a quiet, gentle man who had to “go away” for months at a time on occasion but I never completely understood why. He was a medic. I did over hear the adults saying his family would sometimes have to hide from him because he had nightmares and awoke to what he thought was VC. It was truly the war no one wanted to talk about-certainly not to children.
After hearing the plight of the women, who served in Vietnam I have a question. Is there a memorial for them in DC?
Kristin Hannah, thank you for your work! You are such an inspiration to this aspiring author. I hope that one day I can say I’ve left my mark in such a meaningful way as this. Well done!
See moreSee lessI will start by saying...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
I will start by saying I don't ever remember giving a Hannah book 5 stars. I find that her older books are great beach reads, and some of the newer books she has published have been overly ambitious. I hated the Nightengale, and I thought the Great Alone was awful. The Four Winds was ok but more of a history lesson on The Dust Bowl.
However, 'The Women' is quite an accomplishment. Not only does Hannah nail the history lesson, she pulls the listener in with her to experience the devastation of war, the loss of love, and the comfort of friendship and partnership. This book is raw. It brings to life a perfect picture of the horrible treatment our veterans suffered when coming back from Vietnam. BUT, it focuses on the plight of the females who were in Vietnam, and no one knew it!
If you want to experience a wonderful time piece full of rich history and abundant human strength and spirit, get your Kleenex out and listen to this beautiful book.
Way to go Ms. Hannah- you knocked this out of the ball park. I so enjoyed this listen!
-Wendi
See moreSee lessI have read a lot...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
I have read a lot of Kristin Hannah earlier work.
I listened to this book in three days. The narrator was wonderful.
My reading likes are all across the board in many genres.
From the start I enjoyed the “ stay tough” writing of the nurses and soldiers that gave so much in the Vietnam War.
As Kristin was, I was in elementary school when “the War” hit its heights.
I remember it well. The growing number of casualties, the protesting, the journalists capturing the atrocities and finally the long overdue acknowledgement of a war lost.
Of lives lost. Of the living lives lost.
And lastly the images of the last choppers taking off from Saigon.
If you are of this time. You will enjoy remember, and honor all who lived, died, and honor their
Sacrifice, resilience and grit.. of pushing through. Thank you.
Thank you Kristin for taking the time to do the deep research to construct a beautiful story.
Your forward says it all.
See moreSee lessIf you are a fan...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
If you are a fan of Kristen Hannah’s work, you know that she is a master of writing feelings that jump off the page and into our hearts. This book was no different.
I am not familiar with anything military related but grew to appreciate so much just from reading this book. I absolutely LOVE that Kristen highlighted the forgotten women who served! What a beautiful and honest story written with integrity, respect, and love. So much research was done over many years to make this book possible. What a true labor of love!
Even if the military theme makes you shy to pick up this book, I would highly encourage you to give it a try (I was a little intimidated at first too) I am so glad I read this. Kristen’s writing is something that stays with you long after the final word. Beautiful as always. I would recommend this book to anyone. Best book I have read in a while!
See moreSee lessWow! One of the best...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
Wow! One of the best books I have read in a while! One of those books you think about when you are not reading, this book even crept into my dreams. I had various emotions reading the book, happiness, laughter, anger, and anguish. The Women took me on a journey of the women who served in the Vietnam War, mostly nurses in the makeshift hospitals, and the unbreakable bond of friendship. It painted a picture of the past and all the ugly truths that came with it. It is a remarkable book about the horrors of war and living with the trauma afterward. Listen to the book, share the book, and learn about American history. My husband & I took our sons to see the Vietnam Veterans Memorial in person a few years ago in DC and it had so many names of those who served and sacrificed their life. A generation lost.
See moreSee lessI just finished this amazing...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
I just finished this amazing story and couldn’t stop crying for the last 30-45 minutes! I was young when my father returned from Vietnam and this story shed light on so much, as well as my parents’ resistance to talk about it, and their divorce. This felt so personal and healing to listen to! The women and their friendship, always being there for each other… I’m so grateful for the amazing women in my life… those who are there through everything! This book makes me sad for our veterans and the way they were treated and are still treated and makes me stop and think of the current political climate! Thank you Kristin Hannah for doing such a great job on telling this story and in such an honorable, honest way! This might be my new favorite work of yours! Highly recommend!! Narrator was fabulous too!!!
See moreSee lessThank you Kristin Hannah!
Reviewed on www.business.walmart.com·Timothy
If you lived through the late sixties and early seventies you'd know Hannah has captured those time in the little intimate moments of her story. It's easy to criticize the government in retrospect, but Hannah shows us that when you're living in the moment it's very easy to be swept away in a blind desire to "serve." Of course, the other side of that coin is that having experienced those times and suffered under the pall of doubt regarding your future (caused by the war and the selective service) one never again trusts their government and always and forever holds within them a resentment that we were lied to about the need for that war and then we were lied to about the execution of that war and worst of all we can now see that never was th...
See moreSee lessThank you Kristin Hannah for...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
Thank you Kristin Hannah for blessing this world with the gift to write. Every time I read or listen to one of your stories I think, this was the best book I have ever read. May I also add that audio books are one of my favorite ways to “read” and Julia Whalen is simply the most incredibly talented performer I have ever had the pleasure of listening to. Together the two of you dominate in storytelling. I laughed. I cried. I cried some more. Hell, I am crying now. This book hit me so hard. We need our stories told. We need our girls to hear what we have survived for them. So they can pick up the torch and keep up the fight and to never give up. We will all survive together. Thank you thank you thank you ❤️😭⭐️🇺🇸👩⚕️
See moreSee lessI loved this book! I...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
I loved this book! I was born in the 1980’s and although I knew how controversial the Vietnam War was, I didn’t really understand why. I also never thought about how women served in the war, and the effect it would’ve had on them. I feel ashamed to say, but whenever I’ve heard of a “Vietnam Vet” I’ve always thought of them as men. It made me so angry that even some of their families didn’t acknowledge their heroism. I love that Kristin Hannah can bring to life an event in history, and take you through the emotional journey of the people that lived through it. I couldn’t stop listening. I feel enlightened and I’m so thankful for the brave women and men that serve in our military.
See moreSee lessThe entire story resonated with...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
The entire story resonated with me. My husband spent two tours in Vietnam in combat, Special Forces, Delta and 101st Abn, while I birthed our son, then when our daughter was barely one year old. So, the descriptions and sounds of war hit hard during those pages. Kristen Hannah has always been one of my favorite writers, but I have never been personally brought into a book as I have this one. I hesitate to write anything that might give any hint to the story of Frankie and her experiences. So, I leave it to you to read or listen to the words, as I have, to be totally enveloped into these women who were heroes but went unrecognized for too many years.
See moreSee lessEver since my first Kristin...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
Ever since my first Kristin Hannah book (Firefly Lane,) I’ve been hooked. It is extremely rare to find an author that never disappoints, and she is certainly one of them. True to form, this book makes me smile, laugh, cry, and most importantly, experience stories from a different time. Before reading this I, like many (as demonstrated throughout the book,) rarely thought about the trials and tribulations of the women and nurses not only in Vietnam, but also in wars and conflicts across centuries and throughout the world. Thank you Kristin, for never failing to open my eyes and tug at my heartstrings.
See moreSee lessI always appreciate an author...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
I always appreciate an author that can write truthful and relatable stories. Without the sugarcoated hallmark endings. Kristin Hannah’s books are very detailed and you can tell there has been a lot of research and interviews behind the writing of her books. By far one of her best yet. Very real and heartbreaking. Shining a light on real issues that women of the Vietnam war experienced as well as the aftermath of the war and the standpoint of the country during the war. During a time that a lot of us may not remember or were alive to experience. Worth binge reading.
See moreSee lessAs a nurse from a...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
As a nurse from a different time, who served veterans, and worked with healthcare combat heroes, this book meant so much to me. What an important time in history to capture the details of an undervalued group who persisted through it all and walked through the doubts and jeers of others and survived and stayed true to their core.
It’s a tale of facing vulnerability and digging deep to find the real source of the pain. It’s a story about finding your crew, never leaving them behind and sharing your strength when they are beat down. She captured it all beautifully!
See moreSee lessVery moving
Reviewed on www.audible.com
This is such an amazing book. I think so many have forgotten our history and this is an important read. My dad did 3 tours in Vietnam and was a special forces paratrooper. He was in a helicopter crash and was honorably discharged. I used to touch his scars from the crash and ask him what happened. Most of the time he couldn’t speak. My mom told me not to ask him again and she told me. He still has nightmares and the lasting effects of agent orange on his body have been horrible. My prayers and gratitude go out to all veterans and their families.
See moreSee lessThis story pulled on all...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
This story pulled on all of my emotions. Laughter, anger, empathy, fear, and sadness. Kristan Hannah has away of telling a story that brings history front and center. Making you feel like you are there. I decided to listen to this one on Audible when I found out Julia Whelan was the narrator. She did a beautiful job bringing the story to life. This one will sit with me for some time. It hit me in my gut. It also made me want to go back and watch reruns of M*A*S*H!! There is a reason people are talking about this book. It’s a must read!! 
See moreSee lessJust an amazing story based...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
Just an amazing story based on the women who served in Viet Nam who were such a critical yet oft forgotten part of the war.
When the author picks a subject that can educate and Entertain like this , I wish the book would never end !
Simply brilliant.
I grew up primarily in the late 60’s and 70’s and I vividly recall images of war on tv and even though my parents did their best to shield me during these critical years of my life I still remember even as a child how afraid I was of being sent to war.. mega thanks to the author!
See moreSee lessKristin Hannah writes extremely well....
Reviewed on www.walmart.com·Charlotte
Kristin Hannah writes extremely well. She has a way of writing which introduces the characters while also showing you who they are, really, not a stereotype. She will bring you into her Historical Novels with ease and delight. She has written many novels and I hope to read them all. My first introduction to her was The Nightingale. She celebrates the role and power of seemingly ordinary women, and what we accomplish when needed. She has become one of my favorite Authors, and she is certainly worthy of the title “AUTHOR”.
See moreSee lessBeing an Arm Nurse Corp...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
Being an Arm Nurse Corp member from 1969-1976, though not having served in Vietnam, this wonderfully researched and written historical novel, was bittersweet in its memories of men and women who served and survived as well as those who served and were lost. Its stirring narrative could not have better captured, displayed and honored all who served during these tumultuous years. My sincere thanks and appreciation for your insight and your courage in presenting the pain, the joy and the courage of the men and women who served.
See moreSee lessWell… Kristin Hannah does it...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
Well… Kristin Hannah does it again! The combo of her writing and narration by Julia Whelan is perfection! Not going to lie… I put them both on a very tall pedestal but deservingly so! Ive always made sure to tell those with hats or clothing showing they serve our country, “thank you for your service.” However, after listening to this, it give me a whole new level of appreciation for what those who serve and their families endure. Thank you isn’t enough, but it’s a start. The Women is wonderful and would highly recommend!
See moreSee lessI have read many of...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
I have read many of Kristin Hannah’s novels and love them all. But as a huge fan of historical fiction Nightengale has always been my favorite even though Magic Hour and Four Winds imagery constantly pops up in my brain. The Woman is up there for historical fiction with Nightengale with the emotions and imagery of magic hour. The struggles of a woman finding her way in life through a war and the aftermath of a war that impacted all of us. A must read. Loved it. And the detail and respect for history is overwhelming.
See moreSee lessThis is an important and...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
This is an important and masterfully told story of a difficult time in our nations history. In particular I love the perspective of women who have too often been brushed aside, undervalued, and demeaned throughout ALL of human history. It brings tears to my Eyes to think how far women have come thanks to the trail blazing of the fiercest and resilient women of all time, in many different times and contexts, who were just trying to do the right thing the best they could. Julia whelan, as always, is a master narrator.
See moreSee lessI am an avid reader....
Reviewed on www.audible.com
I am an avid reader. I read so many books, but I look forward to reading any book by Kristin Hannah. The Women did not let me down. I was born in 1975, I had an Uncle that served in Vietnam, he sadly took his own life. I have a better understanding of what life was like for Vietnam veterans but more importantly the women who served as well after reading this book. Bravery and sacrifice are reflected in the lives of the people in this book, thank you Kristin Hannah for telling their stories in such a profound way.
See moreSee lessA good read
Reviewed on www.walmart.com·cvbpackman
I had two brothers that did two tours each in the Army in Vietnam. Neither of them wanted to share any of their experiences but the few they did were very similar to some used in this book. Kristin Hannah does an incredible job of setting the scene and background in her novels. I thoroughly enjoyed this novel even though it brought back very bad memories of how the vets were treated upon returning home. The American public and government are the ones that should bear the shame.
See moreSee lessI loved everything about this...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
I loved everything about this book. The characters are believable, the story has many weep zones. This was my father’s war and he worked in a hospital. I for sure read this book from a different perspective than most. My heart ached for these women who were told over and over that there were no women in Vietnam. I read a lot of historical fiction and if there is a war, I love to read about the women. This book will be one I recommend over and over again.
See moreSee lessA life changing story about...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
A life changing story about the Vietnam War and the forgotten women who served. As a child growing up in the 60’s the war was a backdrop to my formative years and those of my family and friends. The history, music, politics and experiences for my generation are imprinted in our DNA. Being too young at the time to understand, this novel educated and informed me for which I am grateful. Thank you to all who served including the women previously forgotten.
See moreSee lessThis was the best book...
Reviewed on www.audible.com
This was the best book I have listened to in a long time; the kind where you have to stop and sit down and just listen to what is being said. I was 12 years old when the war finally ended, so I grew up during the Vietnam war. I learned more listening to this book than I did in the 12 years I lived it. It truly was the war that no one talked about. And I was embarrassed to be reminded of how we treated them all when they all came home.
See moreSee lessI absolutely loved this book....
Reviewed on www.audible.com
I absolutely loved this book. Got through it in one weekend. Julia Whalen never disappoints. This story was so great. I was born in 1970 and sadly know very little about Vietnam. This was so insightful, and my heart broke for Frankie and her friends at being dismissed for their service to our country. Thank you for bringing this to light, and for sharing the immense hardships faced during and after the war for these amazing veterans.
See moreSee less